I wondered that the first time I saw the
expression. I stumbled across it while researching the probate exception for a
brief I was writing to the federal Fifth Circuit. I saw it in Professor Peter
Nicholas treatise titled: “FIGHTING THE PROBATE MAFIA: A DISSECTION OF THE
PROBATE EXCEPTION TO FEDERAL COURT JURISDICTION“. The good professor
does not define the expression in his treatise and in fact, the words “probate
mafia” only appear in the title. The expression does not appear in the text of
the treatise itself.
What is a Mafia?
According to wikipedia: “Mafia” is an informal term that is used to
describe criminal organizations that bear a strong similarity to the Sicilian
Mafia. The central activity of such an organization would be the
arbitration of disputes between criminals as well as the organization and
enforcement of illicit agreements between criminals through the use of or
threat of violence. Mafias often engage in secondary activities such as
gambling, loan sharking, drug-trafficking, prostitution, and fraud.
What is Probate?
Probate is an action in rem. In actions in rem “the
thing” itself is impugned as the defendant and all
claims are against the thing.
People die and by virtue of that act they abandon all of their worldly
possessions. If the decedent’s property is of any significance,
or a dispute over its disposition, transfer of title to the property must
usually be settled formally. Thus, when someone dies, their property forms an
abstraction called an estate (estate of John/Jane Doe). This abstraction is a
container object created by operation of law to hold all of the decedents stuff
while rights to the “property” are determined. These rights are usually
determined by specialty courts that have been established for that purpose. I
will will not bother with distinctions between
district or superior courts sitting in probate or county courts at law or
statutory probate courts as none of that adds anything
but confusion. This, none-the-less, leads us back to the initial question with
a couple of the blanks filled in: What is the probate mafia?
In my experience the probate mafia is a criminal enterprise conducted by
attorneys, judges and other licensed professionals, using the state probate
courts for the purpose of intercepting (stealing) family generational asset
transfers, sometimes referred to as inheritance hijacking by thieves with
PhDs.
First of all let’s talk about certainty. If one is not busy being born, one
is busy dying. That is a certainty. The uncertainty is in when and how one will
pass. Another uncertainty is “what will happen to your stuff when you die?”
The “Grift of the Brunstings” is a case study that stands for the
proposition that it doesn’t matter what plans you make, what you intend to go
to your heirs will end up in the pockets of attorneys and other probate mafia
participants. I’m going to provide a link to a vital piece in the puzzle because an integral part of
the manner in which the color-of-law mafia operates so successfully is juridically manufactured immunity. In other words, they
have declared themselves above the law under the pretext of agency.